South Jersey Bakeries That Will Satisfy Your Pie Craving

With everything from French apple to sweet potato, these South Jersey bakeries have your pie craving covered.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BXLQb32gm6v/?taken-at=15149892

Penza’s Pies at the Red Barn Café

375 Route 206, Hammonton
609-567-3412
We know Penza’s Pies are great (that’s why we named them a Best of SJ). And if you’re craving tons of fruit with crumbling butter and sugar, this is the place to go.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BYqW-Izgp3w/?taken-by=johnsonscornerfarm

Johnson’s Corner Farm

133 Church Road, Medford
609-654-8643
What’s better than pie filling freshly picked on the farm? Johnson’s pie flavors vary by season, because they use their own crops to bake the flaky and fruity creations. Stop by to see what’s in season.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BWajuPJAq2w/?taken-by=the.pie.lady

The Pie Lady

9 East Main Street, Moorestown
856-778-7437
After a stint baking and delivering baked goods from her own kitchen, The Pie Lady decided to open her own shop – and we’re so happy she did. Grab everything from classic apple crumb to coconut custard and chocolate pecan at this one-stop pie shop.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BbRmkPKgOOg/?taken-by=sweettsbakeshop

Sweet T’s Bakeshop

14 Kings Court, Haddonfield
856-428-0222
If you’re craving the Thanksgiving classics, Sweet T’s Bakeshop has you covered. From pecan pie to pumpkin (with a merengue topping), these staples will have everyone giving thanks for baked goods.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BDriGM7zIO6/?taken-at=240828995

McMillan Bakery

15 Haddon Avenue, Westmont
856-854-3094
Want a pie baked with almost a century of love? Check out McMillan Bakery. It’s been around since 1939 and is still delivering sweet pastries, including classic pies with gooey insides.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BRtJcyNB-Lj/?taken-by=msweeteas

Ms. SweeTea’s

706 Blackwood Clementon Road
856-258-5020
Take your pie with a side of southern comfort. With daily dessert specials that have included oatmeal cream pies and pecan pie, it’s a delicious surprise at Ms. SweeTea’s. And if you can’t wait for the special, place your own order (did someone say sweet potato pie?).