We know the beloved Sesame Street character isn’t the only one who loves to indulge with a cookie (or three), because let’s face it, nothing beats a warm, gooey, straight-from-the-oven confection. Check out our list of some of South Jersey’s best cookie creations and get started on your sweet tour.
480 Evesham Road, Cherry Hill
At Classic Cake, satisfying your sweet tooth is as easy as black and white. The bakery’s large black-and-white cookie will fulfil your sugary needs no matter if you eat it down the middle or devour one side at a time. It doesn’t matter how you slice it, we know you’ll enjoy each bite.
Sweet T’s Bakeshop
14 Kings Court, Haddonfield
Wouldn’t it be fun to unleash your inner cookie monster with a batch of cookie monster cookies? At Sweet T’s Bakeshop, you can choose the design of your treat with an order of their custom cookies. Take a pack of pastel onesies for your next baby shower or a handful of mustaches for a party.
Cake Stand Bakery
2999 Evesham Road, Voorhees
Cake Stand is not for the faint-of-heart cookie consumer. You can get not one, but two large cookies with a sweet filling in between. The bakery switches up flavors on a weekly basis, so you’ll find mouth-watering combos like M&M cookies with chocolate ganache or molasses cookies with cream-cheese filling. It’s the perfect reason to justify a visit every week (or every few days).
Crazy Susan’s Cookies
1345 West Avenue, Ocean City
Satisfy your crazy cookie craving with an even crazier cookie. Check out Crazy Susan’s Cookies for wild flavors and colorful combos, including the crazy turtle, S’mores, and peanut butter fluff — made with actual marshmallow fluff.
15 Haddon Avenue, Haddon Township
If you’re in the mood for an old-fashioned indulgence, visit this fourth-generation bakery. After 76 years of churning out donuts, cakes, and cinnamon buns, McMillan’s is still serving the old favorites. Grab a sand dollar, pinwheel or a handful of butter cookies and enjoy a taste of the classics.
Posh Pop Bakeshop
109 Kings Highway East, Haddonfield
Do you love the idea of a cookie overload, but can’t take the gluten? Posh Pop Bakeshop’s cookie sandwiches are big and bold – and they’re gluten free! Pop into this Haddonfield spot any day of the week to sink your teeth into one of their ginormous goodies. Grab a snickerdoodle sandwich or keep it classic with a chocolate chip and rainbow jimmies creation.
667 Haddon Avenue, Collingswood
Leaving biscotti out of your cookie quest would be just wrong, and we know just the place to find a fix for the Italian specialty. DiBartolo Bakery has a biscotti for everyone, whether you’re a plain enthusiast, a fruit-lover or even a chocolate-addict. Just grab your cup of joe and get to dipping.
Ms. Chrissy’s Sweet Café
38 East High Street, Glassboro
If you’re the kind of person who needs more than just a cookie, run to Ms. Chrissy’s Sweet Café. Stick to the classics with a chocolate-dipped Oreo or chocolate-dipped spiced wafer, or take it to the next level with the banana pudding. They add homemade vanilla wafers to satisfy the cookie craving with a fruity punch.